Marc Andreessen 🇺🇸(@pmarca)

The book Bullshit Jobs by David Graeber was wrong in substance but right in gestalt. Many jobs of th...

4.5内容质量
The book Bullshit Jobs by David Graeber was wrong in substance but right in gestalt. Many jobs of th...

TL;DR · AI 摘要

Andreessen认为Graeber《狗屁工作》实质错误但直觉正确,指出当代许多工作未来将被视为荒谬,呼应AI时代对劳动意义的反思。

核心要点

  • Graeber对“狗屁工作”的批判在情绪上成立,但在实质分析上不准确。
  • 历史视角看,当前许多职业未来可能被后代视为不可理喻的苦役。
  • AI取代工作引发的意义焦虑,其实早已存在于现有无意义工作中。
#AI#劳动经济学#社会批判
打开原文

Marc Andreessen 🇺🇸 on X: "The book Bullshit Jobs by David Graeber was wrong in substance but right in gestalt. Many jobs of the past would horrify us today -- chimneysweep?? Many jobs of today will horrify our descendents. We actually made people DO that? For their whole LIVES? https://t.co/03krSTdFpn" / X

Don’t miss what’s happening

Image 2
Image 2

Marc Andreessen ![Image 3: 🇺🇸 Image 4](http://x.com/pmarca)

@pmarca

The book Bullshit Jobs by David Graeber was wrong in substance but right in gestalt. Many jobs of the past would horrify us today -- chimneysweep?? Many jobs of today will horrify our descendents. We actually made people DO that? For their whole LIVES?

Image 5: Image
Image 5: Image

Quote

Image 6
Image 6

Sean

@sean_from_earth

·

Apr 19

"but how will people find meaning if AI takes their job?" Buddy, that dumb email job isn't giving anyone meaning today so it's not a real concern - we're already experts at living meaningless lives.

11:10 PM · Apr 20, 2026

·

65.1K Views

79

36

418

44

Read 79 replies